Slowing Growth: The Numbers and What They Show

  • According to the IFPI Global Music Report 2024, streaming revenues grew 10.4% in 2023, well below the pace of around 20% a year or more recorded from 2018 to 2021.
  • Spotify, the global leader with 239 million paying subscribers in the first quarter of 2024 (source: Spotify Investor Relations), has raised its subscription prices, without that translating directly into a surge in revenue for rights holders.
  • Plays, on the other hand, keep climbing fast, as Luminate's data show year after year, but the "share of the pie" has not kept up.

Behind these numbers lies a simple reality: streaming has reached a kind of maturity in its European and North American markets, while today's growth comes mainly from Latin America, Africa and Asia, where ARPU (average revenue per user) remains low.

Back to Basics: How Streaming Makes Money

To understand the equation, you have to look at how the platforms work. Two main models coexist:

  • Freemium (Spotify, Deezer, YouTube Music, Boomplay, etc.): A free tier funded by advertising, plus premium subscriptions with advanced features.
  • Paid subscription only (Apple Music, Tidal, Qobuz): No free tier, a fixed monthly price, unlimited access.

In practice, though, more listening does not mean more money. Streaming revenue is fragmented:

  • A significant share of the audience uses the platforms for free.
  • Average spending per user has stalled in mature markets, and it is far lower in countries such as India or Nigeria.
  • The so-called "pro-rata" payout system dilutes the value of each stream when total listening grows faster than overall revenue:
    • Payments are calculated not on what you yourself listen to, but on a track's share of all the streams generated on the platform.

The Price of a Stream: Dilution and Fractions of a Cent

It all starts with a simple but cruel equation: the more tracks are played overall, the less each individual play earns, because the pot to be shared does not grow at the same pace.

Platform Average payout per stream (USD) Streams needed to earn $1,000
Spotify $0.003 to $0.005 200,000 to 333,000
Apple Music About $0.01 About 100,000
YouTube $0.00069 1,450,000
Deezer $0.0064 156,250

(Sources: Soundcharts, 2019, and Digital Music News, 2018, for Spotify; Digital Music News, 2018, for YouTube and Deezer; Rolling Stone, 2021, reporting Apple's letter to artists, for Apple Music. Figures vary by market, contract and advertising revenue pool.)

Streaming has become an economy of extreme volumes, and the big loser is the "long tail": the millions of tracks on the platforms, most of which got 1,000 plays or fewer over the year, according to Luminate's 2023 figures.

Musical (Over)production: An Ocean of Supply, a Drop of Value

Advances in production and digital distribution, through DistroKid, TuneCore, Amuse and others, mean that some 120,000 new tracks hit streaming services every day (source: Music Business Worldwide, citing Luminate data, 2023). This flood of releases drowns individual listening in a continuous stream, adding to the dilution of payouts and saturating the algorithms as well.

All this abundance is not just good news for listeners. The more music there is, the more thinly listening time, and therefore revenue, gets spread. The upside of this paradox is wider access to music; the downside is the frustration of most artists, for whom streaming remains a way to scrape by rather than make a living.

Star-System Algorithms and Click Capitalism

The logic of global platforms encourages concentration: a handful of artists capture the vast majority of streams. According to a 2020 analysis by the data firm Alpha Data, about 1% of artists generated 90% of all music streams.

  • Automated playlists and algorithmic curation favor the repetition of hits, often at the expense of organic discovery.
  • Emerging markets (India, Africa), where streaming has taken off, are marked by extremely low spending per user and locally adjusted pricing, which drags global value down.

On some local platforms, such as Boomplay or JioSaavn, the free tier comes first: the goal is to win over an audience long before trying to monetize each play through subscriptions.

Emerging Markets: Explosive but "Low-Cost" Growth

From Mumbai to Nairobi, local success stories are spectacular, but little of the money makes it into the global coffers:

  • In India, streaming revenue relies heavily on advertising, with ad rates (CPMs) far lower than in Western markets.
  • Africa, driven by Boomplay and Audiomack, is adding users quickly, but monetization remains weak because of living standards, payment methods and the large share of free listening.

The pattern is clear: growth in plays does not translate directly into growth in revenue as long as local spending power remains constrained. The psychological price point of a subscription, often pegged to local purchasing power, caps how far revenue can rise.

What Comes Next? Toward Fairer Models?

The illusion of streaming as a "cash machine" for everyone is fading. Several ways to reform, or at least diversify, revenue sources are being explored:

  • A "user-centric" model: Deezer has championed, and SoundCloud has adopted for independent artists, payouts based on each listener's own plays rather than the total pool. Early results: some independent artists see their income rise (source: SoundCloud).
  • Tiered offers and super apps: Spotify and YouTube are looking at modular subscriptions (podcasts, audiobooks, video services), while in China, Tencent Music has built a whole commercial ecosystem around streaming (live streaming, merchandise, tipping and more).
  • New ways to make money: TikTok, which is starting to rival YouTube as a place to listen to music, is experimenting with paying creators directly through creator funds.

Music as a Barometer of the Connected World

Taken as a whole, streaming is not a closed bubble. It is a crossroads where local cultures, global strategies and digital economies collide. If revenues are stalling, it is because the market has matured in the West, supply has splintered, and the algorithmic equation rewards mass over depth of listening.

Digital technology has not killed the power of music: it has multiplied it and taken it global, while leaving it, for now, economically fragile. As each platform, from one continent to the next, sets its own rules for what gets heard, the biggest challenge may be to build a stage where the volume of listening finally reconnects with perceived value.

Because in the end, whether in Lagos, Seoul or London, meaning never comes from simply pressing "play," but from the shared, sometimes precarious journey between artist and listener, on the "invisible stage" that the world's platforms have become.

En savoir plus à ce sujet :

04/09/2026

The Sonic Cartographers: How Music Data Analysts Decode Streaming Algorithms to Shape Success

Behind the headline-grabbing stars and viral tracks, there is a subculture shaping our playlists: data analysts are deciphering oceans of listener data, refining how algorithms serve music, and informing the...

31/08/2026

Choosing the Next Song: How Artist Managers Rewire for the Streaming Era

Somewhere between the blue-glow dashboards of Spotify for Artists and the rhythmic pulse of TikTok, a quiet revolution has redrawn the borders of artist management. There was a time when...

27/08/2026

From Gatekeepers to Guides: The Evolving Dance between Digital Distributors and Traditional Labels

Picture Tokyo’s Shibuya, midnight: neon-lit streets pulsing with energy, a DJ in a narrow bar cueing tracks not from a vinyl crate nor a CD wallet, but straight from...

23/08/2026

The Quiet Power of Playlist Curators: Mapping the New Gatekeepers of Global Music

Picture a Friday in Lagos, Seoul, or London: headphones plugged in, screens glowing as millions hit “Play” on their chosen streaming app. What comes next isn’t just a personal...

19/08/2026

When Algorithms Write the Score: Suno and the Remaking of Music Creation

It was once said that music floats freely across borders, but creation—real creation—remained a local, human craft. In the smoky twilight of Abbey Road’s studio, or the...

17/08/2026

Remixing Ownership: The Global Experiment of Music NFTs

Music NFTs—non-fungible tokens tied to music—may sound cryptic, but at heart, they’re digital certificates of ownership or access. Each token is unique, embedded on a blockchain (most...